SD-WAN vs. VPN comparison

Internet-based VPN vs MPLS was the debate for some time, WAN technology has evolved in recent years. During that time, SD-WAN has emerged as an enterprise WAN connectivity solution that provides a combination of cost efficiency, agility, and cloud-friendliness that neither MPLS nor Internet-based VPN can match.

One thing I learned from BioIVT’s transition from Internet-based VPN (Virtual Private Network) to cloud-based SD-WAN is selecting the right networking solution for the use case can have tremendous business impact. In their case, time spent provisioning new locations was reduced by months.

Internet-based VPN, which is the use of IPsec tunnels (or similar encryption methods) and physical or virtual VPN appliances to securely connect multiple sites on a WAN over the public Internet, has been a staple on corporate WANs for years. By providing enterprises a means to reduce bandwidth costs, albeit, with some reliability and performance tradeoffs, Internet-based VPN has served as an alternative to MPLS (Multiprotocol Label Switching) for select WAN connectivity use cases.

While Internet-based VPN vs MPLS was the debate for some time, WAN technology has evolved in recent years. During that time, SD-WAN has emerged as an enterprise WAN connectivity solution that provides a combination of cost efficiency, agility, and cloud-friendliness that neither MPLS nor Internet-based VPN can match. Cloud-based SD-WAN, in particular, has proven to be a game-changer by adding reliability and baked-in security features to the mix.

With all the moving parts involved in making a decision, how can you determine if Internet-based VPN or SD-WAN makes sense for your organization’s use case? We’ll answer that question here.

SD-WAN vs VPN: Benefits and Limitations

When comparing WAN connectivity solutions, cost, performance, reliability, and configuration & maintenance are important to consider. Let’s see how the SD-WAN vs VPN debate stacks up in those categories.

SD-WAN vs VPN: Cost

Both Internet-based VPN and SD-WAN enable enterprises to leverage affordable public-Internet bandwidth. In small deployments, VPN can be an inexpensive solution for a few sites and simple WAN topology. For example, a simple site-to-site connection can be achieved using commodity servers and open source software like Openswan. However, as we saw with BioIVT, the complexity and bottlenecks created by the scaling VPN-based networks can outweigh upfront cost savings by a wide margin.

SD-WAN vs VPN: Performance

Internet-based VPN is inherently tied to the public Internet from a performance perspective. Beyond spikes in congestion impacting performance, traversing long geographical distances generally comes with significant latency on VPN-based WANs.  

Further, VPN lacks performance optimization features like dynamic path selection, QoS (Quality of Service), and application-aware routing that help ensure applications like VoIP and telepresence deliver the required levels of performance. SD-WAN delivers these features, and with cloud-based SD-WAN, latency over significant geographical distances becomes a non-issue. Cato’s SLA-backed global private backbone consists of over 45 PoPs (Points of Presence) around the world. As traffic is routed to the nearest PoP and over Cato’s high-speed backbone, the performance issues associated with the public Internet in the middle-mile are averted.

SD-WAN vs VPN: Reliability

Before the dust settled on the SD-WAN vs MPLS debate, a common argument against both appliance-based SD-WAN and VPN was the lack of an SLA with the public Internet. Enterprises demand predictable, reliable performance. VPN is still reliant upon the public-Internet, but Cato’s SLA-backed global backbone is connected by multiple Tier-1 providers across the globe. This enables the Cato Cloud to deliver predictable service and reliability at levels that meet or exceed MPLS.

SD-WAN vs VPN: Configuration & Maintenance

VPN configuration often entails extensive manual work. IPsec tunneling, IKE (Internet Key Exchange), and NAT-T (Network Address Translation Traversal) require a high level of expertise to configure securely and scale. As more and more sites are added to a WAN, maintaining the network becomes increasingly difficult. This, in turn, leads to performance issues and a disjointed WAN infrastructure.

Paysafe Financial Services experienced the issues associated with scaling VPN first-hand. After multiple mergers and acquisitions, Paysafe was left with a backbone made up of MPLS circuits and Internet-based VPN connections. To create a truly meshed network using Internet-based VPN, Paysafe would have required 210 VPN tunnels, a massive investment of time and resources. According to Stuart Gall, then Infrastructure Architect at Payscale, VPN, in particular, was a pain point on their WAN. In regards to their VPN connectivity, Gall said, “Invariably we’d have someone at a site needing connectivity to a different location, forcing a reprovisioning process. That could take weeks of work with approvals and all.”

The solution Paysafe found for their challenges? Cato Cloud. With Cato, Payscale was able to benefit from automatic, scalable, policy-based configurations and the scalability of a cloud-based service model. As a result, Paysafe was able to streamline WAN configurations and provisioning time and reduce latency by 45% when compared to VPN. Just how much faster was configuration with Cato? According to Gall, “Instead of spending weeks bringing up a new site on MPLS or even a VPN, Cato Socket deployment takes no more than 30 minutes — including unboxing.”

Additionally, while Paysafe adopted discrete security solutions before switching to Cato, the enterprise-grade security features built-in to the Cato network helped to ensure secure scalability without the need to configure additional security appliances like NGFWs (next-generation firewalls).

Decision Time

So, with all that in mind, how do you make a decision on SD-WAN vs VPN? If you’re a small enterprise that only needs to connect a handful of sites, an Internet-based VPN can make sense. However, for use cases where scalability, performance, reliability, and operational agility matter, cloud-based SD-WAN wins the day. Not only does this hold true when comparing features on paper, but Cato customers like Payscale and BioIVT also prove it in the real world.

If you’d like to learn more about what SD-WAN can do for your enterprise, book a Discovery Session today.

Have time for a coffee?

Face to face or over Zoom, we are here to help you.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Read more
You might also be interested in...
Gartner Report 2021 Strategic Roadmap for SASE Convergence
Gartner Report 2021 Strategic Roadmap for SASE Convergence
Digitalization, work-from-anywhere, and cloud computing have accelerated SASE offerings to address the need for secure and optimized access, anytime, anywhere, and on any device.
Industry 4.0 – Talking About a Revolution
Industry 4.0 – Talking About a Revolution
Industry 4.0 represents the next phase of innovation in production processes, merging traditional systems with new digital technologies (IoT, AI, big data, AR, robotics, M2M, real-time analytics, and so on), facilitating automation, agility, and efficiency to create a world of smart manufacturing.
SASE vs. SD-WAN: Achieving Cloud-Native WAN Security
SASE vs. SD-WAN: Achieving Cloud-Native WAN Security
For several years now, the network evolution spotlight has been on SD-WAN, and rightfully so. SD-WAN provides big advancements in connecting branch locations into central data centers in a cost-effective manner. It is the networking equivalent of a killer application that allows companies to use a variety of transport mechanisms besides MPLS and to steer traffic according to business priorities.
Why Remote Work and Legacy Security Architectures Don’t Mix
Why Remote Work and Legacy Security Architectures Don’t Mix
Last week, Cato Networks announced the results of the 5th annual IT survey, The Future of Enterprise Networking and Security: Are You Ready for the Next Leap. It was a massive undertaking that saw 2,376 participants from across the globe provide detailed insights into how their organizations responded to the COVID-19 crisis, their plans for 2021, and what they think about secure access service edge (SASE).
SD-WAN or SASE: Choose a platform rather than a product
SD-WAN or SASE: Choose a platform rather than a product
As enterprises set out to modernize their networks, SD-WAN has become a key networking technology for connecting offices. But with COVID-19, users transitioned to work at home, not in the office.
Thought SD-WAN Was What You Needed to Transform your Network? Think Again.
Thought SD-WAN Was What You Needed to Transform your Network? Think Again.
Since its premier over a decade ago, SD-WAN was adopted by enterprises as the go-to-technology for preparing their network for the digital transformation.
Rethinking Enterprise Remote Access VPN Solutions: Designing Scalable VPN Connectivity
Rethinking Enterprise Remote Access VPN Solutions: Designing Scalable VPN Connectivity
The global pandemic has forced many organizations around the world to send their workers home to support social distancing mandates. The process happened suddenly – almost overnight – giving companies little time to prepare for so many people to work remotely. To keep business functioning as best as possible, enterprises need to provide secure remote connectivity to the corporate network and cloud-based resources for their remote workers.
Secure Remote Work: Deploying Zero Trust Access
Secure Remote Work: Deploying Zero Trust Access
The global pandemic has forced knowledge workers to move out of their offices en masse to the isolated environment of their homes. Most will return to the office at some point, even if only part-time, as companies adjust to social distancing measures meant to keep employees safe.
How much does SD-WAN cost?
How much does SD-WAN cost?
Calculating the cost of SD-WAN can be complicated, especially when it comes to CAPEX vs OPEX and ambiguous ROIs. With so many vendors promising massive savings over MPLS internet connections, SD-WAN is currently been touted as one of the hottest categories in networking today. Take a closer look at the costs, considerations, potential savings and leverage the SD-WAN calculator to estimate your organisations SD-WAN cost.
Considerations for a branch office firewall
Considerations for a branch office firewall
Organisations looking for a branch office firewall upgrade, refresh or deploying firewalls to new sites, need to consider multiple different elements. Let's walk through all of the major factors to consider for a branch firewall and why organisations should consider SD-WAN, and more recently Secure Access Service Edge (SASE) as part of their next-generation of branch network security.
What is STaaS?
What is STaaS?
Storage as a service (STaaS) is a managed service model for purchasing data storage based on consumption, where a company only pays for what they use, typically on a per-GB per-month basis.
What is SD-WAN?
What is SD-WAN?
Software-Defined WAN (SD-WAN) is a networking technology that seamlessly connects branch offices, HQs cloud and data centers over broadband internet rather than MPLS leased lines.
SD-WAN vs. MPLS vs. broadband public internet
SD-WAN vs. MPLS vs. broadband public internet
To meet the needs of a global enterprise, our network architectures need to evolve as well. Which architectural approach will best serve your needs — MPLS, public internet or cloud networks?
SD-WAN vs. MPLS: Choose the best WAN solution for you
SD-WAN vs. MPLS: Choose the best WAN solution for you
You've probably heard about SD-WAN and its promise to transform enterprise networking as we know it. And, by enterprise networking we mean the use of MPLS at the core of enterprise networks. So, to SD-WAN or to MPLS? Here is what you need to consider.
Alternatives to MPLS internet
Alternatives to MPLS internet
SD-WAN is looking to address the challenges of MPLS like cost, capacity, rigidity, and manageability.
Challenges of SD-WAN security
Challenges of SD-WAN security
A good starting point in explaining why cloud-native SD-WAN is so compelling from a security perspective is the shortcomings of two older WAN solutions: MPLS and appliance-based SD-WAN.
WAN Optimization in the SD-WAN Era
WAN Optimization in the SD-WAN Era
WAN optimization has been with us for a long time. Born alongside expensive and capacity constrained WAN connectivity, such as MPLS, WAN optimization appliances allowed organizations to squeeze more bandwidth out of thin pipes through compression, and prioritize traffic of loss-sensitive applications such as remote desktops.
History of SD-WAN
History of SD-WAN
Let's take a look at the history of WAN and as we journey from Point-to-Point, T1/T3, Frame Relay, to MPLS, and finally arrive at SD-WAN.
How to load balance multiple internet connections?
How to load balance multiple internet connections?
Internet load balancing or fail-over for multiple internet connections can seem like a tight rope walk, but it doesn't have to be. There are multiple ways to accomplish it, from point products to routers and firewalls. Let's take a look at the options and alternatives.
How does SD-WAN work?
How does SD-WAN work?
SD-WAN has quickly become the go-to technology for enterprises seeking to leverage the cloud and embrace digital transformation. Yet, much confusion still exists about what exactly is an SD-WAN, and how the technology works.
WAN Optimization vs. SD-WAN
WAN Optimization vs. SD-WAN
With the rising popularity of SD-WAN, there is a growing debate that WAN optimization is becoming obsolete. SD-WAN is gaining acceptance and for good reason. It creates an intelligent overlay of multiple transports on your WAN to efficiently and automatically route traffic over the most optimal path.
How to connect multiple branch offices?
How to connect multiple branch offices?
How do you connect multiple offices rapidly and affordably without sacrificing performance?
Last mile constraints for SD-WAN
Last mile constraints for SD-WAN
From pairing MPLS with a backup internet connection, to link-bonding for aggregate last-mile, SD-WAN introduces new ways to handle old problems, with policy-based routing, active/active links, packet loss mitigation, and quality of service (QoS).
Affordable MPLS Alternatives
Affordable MPLS Alternatives
After decades of use, enterprises are looking for MPLS alternatives. To be considered a viable alternative, a network must match MPLS’ service levels for predictability and consistency, while avoiding its pitfalls of cost, rigidity and capacity constraints.
SD-WAN vs. MPLS redundancy
SD-WAN vs. MPLS redundancy
How can SD-WAN deliver the same reliability and redundancy as MPLS when it uses the public Internet?
How does SD-WAN benefit digital transformation?
How does SD-WAN benefit digital transformation?
Digital transformation is all about agility. SD-WAN enables organisations to be more agile in multiple different ways. Such as the ability to rapidly stand-up a new site with secure internet and inter-office connectivity, without the need for additional security appliances, make policy changes across multiple sites on-the-fly, gain real-time visibility of users and connections, on-board new VPN users for remote work without worries license or connection limits.
Evolution of SD-WAN
Evolution of SD-WAN
SD-WAN has become more than just a network for connecting locations. The rise of cloud, mobile, and business agility demands has required SD-WAN to become smarter by providing security, optimization, intelligence, and better reach. These changes in SD-WAN can be broken down into three phases, reflecting the ways that SD-WAN technologies have adapted over time to the demands of business requirements.